The Supreme Court of Canada on Thursday refused to hear an appeal that challenged how British Columbia’s foreign buyer tax applies to a jointly owned property, leaving a lower-court ruling in place. The case involved a Canadian citizen, Chia-Wen Hsia, who registered 95 per cent ownership of a Richmond, B.C. apartment while her foreign-national partner, Li-Yuan Chuang, registered only 5 per cent — even though he had actually paid 40 per cent of the purchase price.
The couple, engaged when they bought the unit under a presale contract in 2014, paid B.C.’s 20-per-cent foreign buyer tax only on the 5 per cent registered to Chuang. A later audit found the tax was payable on the fair market value of the entire property, adding roughly $126,000 to their bill. The B.C. Supreme Court dismissed their challenge in 2024, and a three-judge panel of the B.C. Court of Appeal later found the couple could have avoided the full-value tax by registering ownership in proportion to their actual contributions. The property, declared at $474,500 at purchase, is now assessed at $820,000.
The couple’s lawyer, Massao Morinaga, said they had no comment on the Supreme Court’s dismissal, calling it the “end of the road judicially,” but added that the current foreign buyer tax legislation is drafted in a way that “captures situations that are inequitable.” The B.C. government had argued the rule is meant to prevent tax avoidance by foreign investors who hold beneficial interests indirectly through others.
References
Castanet.net – Supreme Court of Canada dismisses bid to appeal B.C. foreign buyer tax case






