*Written and verified by Zagdim Research. Last verified: 15 November 2026.*
The Reader’s Letter
Hello Zagdim,
>
My family bought an off-plan serviced apartment in Malaysia. When the sale and purchase agreement was signed, a guaranteed rental return agreement was signed with it, paying a fixed percentage of the purchase price each year for the first 9 years. The property has never been completed. Five or six years have passed without construction starting, and it looks as though the project may be abandoned. The developer did not deduct any tax when paying the return, and is now negotiating an exit arrangement that is not a full refund. My family are not Malaysian tax residents. Is this return taxable in Malaysia? It is not even built, so does it count as rental income? Reports say non-resident rental income is taxed at 30%, but I have also heard the return is taxed at 10%. Which is it? And since the developer did not deduct tax, can we treat the payments as a return of capital and not report them?
>
To protect the reader, some details (such as age, city or dates) have been slightly changed; this does not affect the answer.
Zagdim’s Answer
Dear reader, thank you for writing in. Whether the return is taxed, and whether the rate is 30% or 10%, depends on which class of income the Inland Revenue Board of Malaysia (LHDN) puts it in, and LHDN has no published ruling on guaranteed returns that developers pay to off-plan buyers. If it is classed as rent, a non-resident individual files a return and the rate is 30%. If it is classed as other gains under section 4(f), the payer withholds 10% and that is a final tax. If it falls under 4(f), the developer must account for the tax whether or not it deducted any, although after paying it the developer may recover the amount from the recipient. Whether a payment is income or a return of capital depends on the contract and the facts of the case, and no official rule lets a recipient simply relabel it as capital. Zagdim suggests your family take the contract to LHDN and ask for a written reply.
Key Points
- Under Public Ruling (PR) 12/2018, income from letting real property is divided into 4(a) business source and 4(d) non-business source. Gains that fall under none of the other paragraphs are listed under 4(f).
- A non-resident individual is taxed at 30% of chargeable income. Under 4(f), the payer withholds 10% of the gross amount, and PR 1/2010 states this is a final tax.
- For 4(f), the payer must report and pay within one month of the payment. An unpaid amount carries a 10% increase, and the payer may recover the tax from the recipient (section 109F).
- Who should pay attention: people who buy off-plan property in Malaysia with a guaranteed rental return agreement and are not Malaysian tax residents.
What the Official Rules Say
Which Class of Income a Guaranteed Rental Return Falls Under
The titles on LHDN’s list of public rulings, PR 12/2018 and PR 1/2010 all fail to address this payment. Under section 4 of the Income Tax Act, 4(d) is “rents, royalties or premiums” and 4(f) is “gains or profits not falling under any of the foregoing paragraphs.” PR 12/2018 further divides letting of real property into 4(a), a business source, and 4(d), a non-business source.
Whether It Is Rent When the Building Is Unfinished
The official text does not say whether this money is rent when the property has not been completed. “Rent” in section 2(1) includes payments for the use or occupation of premises, and paragraph 3.6 of PR 12/2018 reads “for the use or occupation of any real property.” Paragraph 6.1 says a 4(d) rental source starts from the date the property is first let. An off-plan property has no one using or occupying it, so the answer is for LHDN to decide.
When 30% Applies and When 10% Applies
The 30% and 10% rates belong to different classes and do not apply together.
| Class | Rate | How it is paid |
|---|---|---|
| 4(d) rent | 30% of chargeable income for a non-resident individual (Schedule 1, Part I, paragraph 1A) | The recipient files a return; withholding under section 109 covers only interest and royalties |
| 4(f) other gains | 10% of the gross amount (Schedule 1, Part XIII) | The payer withholds; paragraph 9 of PR 1/2010 says it is “a final tax” |
Paragraph 4.3 of PR 1/2010 lists tests for 4(f), including that the income is of an income rather than a capital nature, that it is miscellaneous or occasional, and that it comes from a one-off transaction. Whether regular payments over 9 years meet them is for LHDN to decide.
The Developer Did Not Deduct Tax: Who Is Responsible
If the payment falls under 4(f), section 109F(1) says the payer must report and pay “whether or not that tax is so deducted,” within one month of payment. An unpaid amount is increased by 10% (section 109F(2)), and the Director General may waive all or part of the increase at their discretion (section 109F(4)). After the payer pays, it may recover the tax from the recipient (section 109F(3)(b)).
Can It Be Treated as a Return of Capital and Not Reported
No provision allows a recipient to relabel what it received as a return of capital. Paragraph 4.3 of PR 1/2010 says whether income falls under 4(f) “depends on the facts and circumstances of each case.” Whether the return is income or an adjustment to the purchase price depends on what the contract actually says, and LHDN decides.
How This Applies to the Reader
| Your family’s situation | Official rule | Result for now |
|---|---|---|
| Not a tax resident | Resident if present in Malaysia 182 days or more in the basis year (section 7(1)(a)); sections 7(1)(b) to (d) also treat some people with under 182 days as resident | Must be checked year by year |
| Fixed return for 9 years | No published ruling | Class undecided |
| Property not under construction | Rent presupposes use or occupation | No explicit official text |
| Developer deducted no tax | Under 4(f), the payer is liable and may recover from the recipient | If it is 4(f) and the developer pays, your family may be asked to repay it |
| Wish to treat it as capital | Depends on the facts and contract | No official rule on relabeling |
Exceptions and What to Confirm
- Classification: Whether it falls under 4(a), 4(d), 4(f) or a purchase price adjustment must be confirmed with LHDN in writing.
- If the developer recovers the tax: What more the recipient must do is not stated officially and must be confirmed with LHDN.
- Exit arrangement that is not a full refund: How the refund and the loss are treated is not covered here, because the official rules and the real property gains tax text were not obtained. Confirm with LHDN.
- Double tax agreements and purchase through a company: How treaties treat this kind of income, and the rate for a non-resident company, must be confirmed with LHDN.
- Version of the legislation: This article uses the Income Tax Act text updated on May 21, 2024 and posted on LHDN’s website, which is marked as not an official text. Confirm the current provisions with LHDN.
- Civil claims over an abandoned project: Whether the guaranteed return contract falls within the sale and purchase agreement, and whether a serviced apartment counts as residential, must be confirmed with TPPS under the Ministry of Housing and Local Government (KPKT), in connection with the Tribunal for Homebuyer Claims (TTPR).
Next Steps
- Find the sale and purchase agreement and the guaranteed rental return agreement, and check how each clause describes the payments, the payment timing and who bears tax.
- Through LHDN’s official website, ask in writing, attaching the contract clauses, which class the return falls under and whether the recipient must declare it when the payer has not withheld.
- List the days each family member spent in Malaysia in each basis year.
- If a return is needed, a non-resident individual uses Form M, and if there is no business income it is due by April 30 of the following year. If the income falls under 4(f), ask LHDN whether the developer has paid the tax using CP37F.
- For civil remedies over the abandoned project and the refund, read the TTPR question and answer page of KPKT first, then confirm eligibility with TPPS.
FAQ
Can the exit refund be claimed at the Tribunal for Homebuyer Claims?
The Tribunal for Homebuyer Claims (TTPR) hears only claims that arise from a sale and purchase agreement between a buyer and a housing developer, and only in Peninsular Malaysia and Labuan. Each claim is capped at RM50,000, and a higher amount needs both sides’ written consent. The filing fee is RM10. If a sale and purchase agreement ended before the Certificate of Completion and Compliance (CCC) was issued, the claim must be filed within 12 months of termination. Apartments, condominiums and SOHO units are covered, and commercial buildings are not. Whether a serviced apartment is included depends on the TPPS reply.
We hope your family can sort this out soon.
Need help with this? Talk to the Zagdim reader desk
If you are deciding which route fits you, or which authority to deal with, the Zagdim Reader Desk can understand what you need and shortlist suitable professionals for your situation. The Reader Desk does not charge readers.
Message the Zagdim reader desk on WhatsApp Message the Zagdim reader desk on LINE
Have a question about this guide? Leave a comment below, or ask Zagdim directly.
Your first stop for international property and global living.
Research and insights. Know what’s changing. Understand what matters.
Sources
- LHDN, Income Tax Act 1967 (Act 53), text updated 2024-05-21
- LHDN, Public Ruling No. 12/2018 Income from Letting of Real Property
- LHDN, Public Ruling No. 1/2010 Withholding Tax on Income Under Paragraph 4(f)
- LHDN, Withholding Tax (Cukai Pegangan)
- LHDN, Public Rulings
- LHDN, Soalan Lazim Individu
- KPKT, Soalan Lazim Tribunal Tuntutan Pembeli Rumah
This article is based on a question received by the Zagdim Reader Desk; identifying details were changed, and the answer was checked line by line against official sources.
Important Notice
This article is general information and is not legal, tax or immigration advice. Rules and fees may change; check the latest notices from the relevant authority before you apply. Information last checked: 15 November 2026.






